MH370 report clears pilot but says flight controls likely ‘manipulated’
Share this on

MH370 report clears pilot but says flight controls likely ‘manipulated’

THE controls of the ill-fated Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 were likely manipulated deliberately to take it off course, investigators said in a report released on Monday, but the probe has yet to come up with conclusions for the cause of the disaster.

The report said from previous discussions, there is no evidence to suggest a malfunction to divert the Boeing 777 aircraft from its flight path when it disappeared to become one of the biggest mysteries in modern aviation.

“The analysis of the relevant aircraft systems taking into account the route followed by the aircraft and the height at which it flew, constrained by its performance and range capability, does not suggest a mechanical problem with the aircraft,” the report said.

“The aircraft’s maintenance history and events prior to the last flight do not show any issues that could have contributed and resulted in the deviation and subsequent changes in the flight path.”

No conclusions

The 495-page report draws no conclusion about what happened aboard the plane that vanished with 239 people on board en route to Beijing from Kuala Lumpur on March 8, 2014.

“The answer can only be conclusive if the wreckage is found,” Kok Soo Chon, head of the MH370 safety investigation team, told reporters.


Family members speak to the media after an MH370 closed door meeting in Putrajaya, Malaysia July 30, 2018. Source: Reuters

On May 29, Malaysia called off a three-month search by US firm Ocean Infinity, which spanned 112,000 sq km in the southern Indian Ocean and ended with no significant findings.

SEE ALSO: MH370 search team optimistic, final search report due in June 

It was the second major search after Australia, China and Malaysia ended a fruitless AUD$200 million (US$147.06 million) search across an area of 120,000 sq km last year.

Malaysian and international investigators have been looking into why the jet veered thousands of miles off course from its scheduled route before eventually plunging into the Indian Ocean.

The last communication from the plane was from the Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah who signed off with “Good night, Malaysian three seven zero”, as the plane left the Malaysian airspace and later turned off course.

‘Vindicated’ first officer

A 440-page final report by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) last year showed that Zaharie had flown a route on his home flight simulator six weeks earlier that was “initially similar” to the one actually taken by MH370.

The Malaysian police previously concluded there were no unusual activity on the home simulator.

Kok said the investigators examined the history of the pilot and the first officer, and they were satisfied with their background and training and mental health.

“We are not of the opinion it could have been an event committed by the pilots,” he said, but added they were not ruling out any possibility since the in-air turn back was done manually and the systems in the plane were also manually turned off.


In this March 22, 2014 file photo, flight officer Rayan Gharazeddine scans the water in the southern Indian Ocean off Australia from a Royal Australian Air Force AP-3C Orion during a search for the missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370. Source: AP

“We cannot exclude that there was an unlawful interference by a third party,” Kok said, adding all the passengers of the 15 countries had their backgrounds checked by their respective countries and all came back with a clean bill of health.

Sakinab Ahmad Shah, the sister of the flight’s first officer Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah told reporters she felt relieved and happy that her brother was cleared of blame.

“I’m so happy for the fact that he is cleared but at the end of the story, we want the plane or wreckage to be found,” she said as quoted by The Star.

Conspiracy theories and mistakes

The inability to locate MH370’s crash site has fuelled conspiracy theories and online debates over the last four years.Theories range from mechanical error or a remote-controlled crash, to more bizarre explanations like alien abduction and a Russian plot.

Kok said they looked into each theory and rumour raised on social media.

“We had over 60 allegations…we removed them one-by-one and saw what remained behind,” Kok said.

The report said there was no sign the plane was evading radar detection or that it was taken over by remote control. No irregularities were found in the on-board cargo, which included items like lithium batteries and about 2,500 kgs of mangosteen.

SEE ALSO: MH370 search vessel ‘disappears’ for three days 

In all, 27 pieces of aircraft debris have been collected from various places around the world but only three wing fragments that washed up along the Indian Ocean coast have been confirmed to be from MH370.

Malaysia’s newly elected Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad has said Malaysia would consider resuming the search only if new clues come to light.

Investigators highlighted some mistakes made by the Kuala Lumpur and Ho Chi Minh City air traffic control centres and made safety recommendations to ensure such incidents do not occur again.

Transport Minister Antony Loke said in a statement that Malaysia would investigate any misconduct committed based on the findings.


Family members speak to the media after an MH370 closed door meeting in Putrajaya, Malaysia July 30, 2018. Source: Reuters

The next-of-kin of the passengers were briefed on the final report by investigators earlier on Monday.

“We hope that these mistakes will not be repeated and that measures are put in place to prevent them in the future,” said Grace Nathan, a lawyer whose mother, Anne Daisy, was on the plane.

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Geng Shuang said Beijing had paid close attention to the MH370 investigation.

“We hope that all sides can continue to remain in close contact and coordination, to properly carry out relevant follow-up work,” he told a daily news briefing, without elaborating.

The majority of passengers on board were Chinese.

With additional reporting by Reuters