Manila hostage crisis aftermath: reasons and repercussions
By Elmer W. Cagape Aug 24, 2010 8:12AM UTCAt the height of controversy surrounding police brutality allegedly involving a police officer torturing a suspected robber, the seeming incompetence of the police has come to light once more, this time to the international community and earning sharp criticism from folks here in Hong Kong. The Philippine National Police’s reputation may be tarnished, but at a time when the PNP was given the chance to shine before the international community, its name sunk even deeper.
No wonder local Hong Kong people were quick to criticize the Philippine police force as they quickly trooped to social media sites in solidarity and expressed sympathy to those who perished and were traumatized by the incident. They see how the Hong Kong Police act on situations like this and come out as heroes. They may not be perfect but they get the job done most of the time.
Last night thousands of households were glued to their television sets like us, anxiously waiting for developments in a hostage crisis that went awfully wrong. As I write this blog this morning, I am sure people are heading towards their daily supply of tabloids to get a clearer understanding of what took place in Manila. Maybe questions remain after reading the news stories. Why a police officer no longer in service got hold of the high-powered firearm? Why it took the police so long to address the drama? Is the media coverage of the hostage taking partly to blame?
Filipinos ask how could an award-winning police officer end up as the bad guy? The hostage taker, Mr Rolando Mendoza, was honored in 1986 but dismissed a few years ago over alleged involvement in drug-related crimes and extortion, police said. He took the hostages in an effort to win his job back and have his name cleared. Was he a sacrificial lamb persecuted so someone else could get away free?
Maybe it’s in the peace-loving patience and easygoing nature of Filipinos that saw the police wait 12 hours before making a move. If it were in China or the United States, the hostage taker would have been killed much sooner. At times Mr Mendoza looked out of the front door of the bus, putting himself at a vantage point perfect for snipers to pull the trigger. And who knows, if the driver did not escape and screamed “everybody is dead!”, the hostage drama would have stayed in stalemate.
The new regime of President Noynoy Aquino presented new hope for the Filipino people as he was inaugurated barely two months ago in Quirino Grandstand. Alas, that venue would also become the scene of a bloody end to a failed rescue operation of foreign tourists. According to SCMP, Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang tried to call Mr Aquino but failed to get through. “I hope the Philippines government can give me a full account of what happened,” he said. Mr Tsang was close to tears when he spoke in a press conference as he expressed his disappointment over the outcome. The Aquino government issued a statement, but Hong Kong people probably need more answers.
The hostage drama took place in Manila, where supposedly the best equipped and properly trained special forces are ready for deployment. If it happened in a fourth class municipality in the middle of a province in Mindanao, there’s a bit of an excuse. Such a messy outcome led to some Filipinos to question the integrity and capability of the police force by asking if the real meaning of SWAT is Sorry Wala Akong Training (Sorry I Don’t Have Training). And with the arrest of congressman Ronald Singson in Hong Kong for possession of cocaine in recent weeks, Filipinos (at least in social media circles) offered Singson as the pawn: “Dear Hong Kong. You can take it out on Ronald Singson. Be our guest. Regards, The Philippines.”
Hong Kong is a lucrative source of affluent outbound travelers. But the Philippines can no longer expect visitors from the former British colony after a travel ban was issued last night. Such move results in travel agencies taking Boracay, Cebu or Puerto Galera special offers off display. But there could be other repercussions. Filipino domestic helpers may expect a change in how their Hong Kong employers treat them. Filipino tourists visiting Hong Kong could spend more time talking to immigration officers. Let’s find out.
No PR job can restore the severely tarnished name of the Philippine National Police in the eyes of Hong Kong people. Too bad there are members of the police force who “serve and protect” the Philippines the right way diligently, yet helplessly find themselves getting dragged into this mess.



